top of page

Knowledge Transfer and Workplace Safety: How to Protect Essential Competencies

5 days ago
12 min read

Your organisation may be closer to losing essential safety knowledge than you think. AR19 helps companies identify organisational vulnerabilities and strengthen safety culture through assessment, leadership development, human factors and predictive KPIs.


Knowledge transfer in organisations is a fundamental element of risk management, particularly in industrial and safety-critical environments. When an experienced professional leaves a role, the organisation may lose operational know-how, the ability to recognise anomalies and decision-making criteria developed over time. This article explores the relationship between tacit knowledge, human factors and workplace safety. It explains how to identify essential competencies, assess the risk of losing them and build effective knowledge transfer and competence assurance programmes. The aim is to connect people development, safety culture and operational continuity.


Introduction


In an industrial plant, an experienced professional may recognise an anomaly before a system triggers an alarm. They may remember the circumstances that preceded an incident, interpret unusual machine behaviour or understand when a situation requires closer investigation.


These abilities do not come from training alone. They develop through experience, observation and daily exposure to real operating conditions.


When that person leaves the organisation, the risk is not simply the loss of a technical skill. The system may also lose part of its ability to recognise and manage critical situations.


Knowledge transfer therefore goes beyond conventional generational succession.


For industrial organisations, it means protecting a body of knowledge that contributes to people's safety, process reliability and decision-making quality.


The question is not simply who will replace a professional. It is what that person knows, how important that knowledge is for controlling risk and how it can remain available to the rest of the organisation.


In summary


Losing knowledge can increase operational vulnerability when information, experience and decision-making abilities remain concentrated in a few individuals. Companies can reduce this exposure by identifying the competencies essential to safety, assessing their dependence on individual professionals and establishing structured transfer processes. Mentoring, on-the-job coaching, field observations and practical assessments help turn individual knowledge into organisational capability that remains available over time.


Why is knowledge transfer a risk management issue?


Knowledge transfer becomes a risk management issue when the availability of specific competencies affects an organisation's ability to prevent incidents, control processes and handle unexpected situations.


Every company has critical resources: equipment, technologies, infrastructure and information systems. Yet it also relies on less visible assets, such as a team's ability to interpret anomalies or make sound decisions under unusual operating conditions.


These abilities often depend on people's experience and are fundamental to operational safety.


Risk emerges when knowledge essential to process performance and hazard control remains concentrated in a small number of people, without adequate mechanisms to retain and share it.


Retirement, professional mobility, organisational changes and employee turnover can therefore create vulnerabilities that go beyond staffing levels. They can undermine the organisation's ability to remain in control of critical activities.


The problem becomes particularly apparent when the company can no longer access essential knowledge at the moment it is needed.


Consider an extraordinary maintenance activity that requires knowledge of previous anomalies, plant modifications or specific operating conditions. If this information exists only in one professional's memory, their absence may make it harder to assess the situation correctly, recognise warning signs and choose appropriate preventive measures.


From this perspective, losing competencies essential to safety is an organisational vulnerability that can weaken risk management, even when procedures, control systems and formal responsibilities have not changed.


Safety-related competencies should therefore be considered in organisational risk assessments alongside technical resources and operating processes.


The question is not only what a person knows, but which risks the organisation might no longer be able to control without that knowledge.


What is tacit knowledge and how does it influence operational safety?


Tacit knowledge includes the skills, judgement and practical understanding people develop through experience and cannot always fully describe in procedures or documents.


Unlike explicit knowledge, which can be recorded in manuals, instructions and information systems, tacit knowledge emerges mainly through everyday work.


A supervisor may sense that a situation is not developing normally. A maintenance technician may identify a meaningful change in an asset's behaviour. An operator may remember that a particular combination of conditions preceded a critical event.


In each case, experience helps people interpret information that might appear insignificant when considered in isolation.


The relationship with safety is direct: the ability to recognise weak signals helps identify situations that require attention before they develop into more serious events.


However, an important distinction is necessary.


Not all accumulated experience automatically represents good practice.


Years of work can build valuable capabilities, but they can also reinforce habits, operational shortcuts and approaches to risk that are no longer appropriate.


Knowledge transfer should therefore not simply reproduce the behaviour of an experienced colleague.


It should identify useful insights, check their consistency with safety standards and turn them into competencies that others can apply consciously.


In this way, individual knowledge supports organisational learning rather than remaining a personal professional legacy.


How can organisations assess the risk of losing safety-critical competencies?


To assess the risk of losing competencies essential to safety, an organisation needs to understand which capabilities are indispensable to its activities, how much they depend on particular individuals and what could happen if those capabilities became unavailable.


This process is known as Knowledge Loss Risk Assessment.


It is especially relevant in complex industrial environments, where losing knowledge can affect safety, decision-making quality and operational reliability.


An effective assessment can consider three main dimensions.


Knowledge criticality describes the role a competence plays in controlling risk. Not all knowledge has the same impact. Capabilities needed to manage activities with potentially severe consequences deserve particular attention.


Knowledge concentration identifies how many people genuinely possess a competence and how dependent the organisation is on one or a few professionals.


Vulnerability to loss considers how likely that knowledge is to become unavailable and how long it would take to rebuild. Retirement, reassignment, turnover and organisational change can all contribute.


By combining these factors, the company can establish intervention priorities.


For example, specialist knowledge needed to operate a critical plant and held by only one person approaching retirement calls for a priority transfer plan.


This approach is also relevant to the nuclear sector, where retaining professional competencies is an essential element of safety.


Which competencies should be protected first in safety-critical operations?


In safety-critical environments, priority should go to knowledge that directly contributes to preventing serious events, maintaining effective controls and managing abnormal operating conditions.


Identifying it requires a clear connection between processes, risks and the work actually performed.


The UK Health and Safety Executive explains that competence management systems should focus on responsibilities and tasks identified through risk assessment. It also emphasises complex operations, emergencies, maintenance and non-routine situations.


This guidance helps organisations distinguish generally valuable skills from those essential to safety.


Particular attention should be paid to:


  • knowledge needed to recognise abnormal conditions and early warning signs of risk;

  • experience in non-routine operations, maintenance and emergency response;

  • the decision-making criteria used by operators, supervisors and managers to determine when work should stop or support should be requested;

  • organisational memory of incidents, near misses, plant modifications and previous operational difficulties;

  • the competencies needed to verify the effectiveness of controls and safety barriers.


This knowledge is not limited to frontline personnel.


Managers, production leaders, HSE professionals and supervisors may also possess difficult-to-replace competencies, especially when assessing complex situations or making high-impact decisions.


The objective is not to document every individual's experience, but to identify which knowledge enables the organisation to remain in control of its critical risks.


What is the difference between knowledge transfer and competence assurance?


Knowledge transfer allows people to share skills and experience. Competence assurance verifies that they possess, maintain and can apply the capabilities required to perform specific activities safely.


This distinction matters.


An employee may complete a mentoring programme, attend training and understand procedures without yet being able to manage complex operating situations independently.


In high-risk environments, knowledge therefore needs to become demonstrable capability.


The Health and Safety Executive (HSE), the British authority for workplace health and safety, explains that training is an important component of competence development but is not sufficient on its own. Practical experience, supervision and periodic assessments of operational ability are also necessary.


An effective system should connect three elements.


  • Knowledge: what information, principles and procedures does a person need to know?

  • Practical application: how does that person use the knowledge under the operating conditions they will face?

  • Reliability over time: does the organisation periodically check that the competence remains adequate as technologies, processes and working conditions change?


Competence assurance should also consider communication, decision-making, situational awareness and the recognition of weak signals.


These capabilities influence risk management and may not emerge from a purely theoretical assessment.


In this sense, transferring knowledge creates the conditions for competence development. Assessing competence establishes whether those capabilities genuinely contribute to safety.


How can individual experience become organisational capability?


Turning individual experience into organisational capability requires structured opportunities for learning, discussion and practical application. Filing documents or arranging a handover is not enough.


Much tacit knowledge becomes visible when people explain why they make certain decisions, which signals they notice and how they interpret operating conditions. Mentoring and on-the-job coaching are valuable when the organisation establishes clear objectives, responsibilities and expected outcomes.


The European Agency for Safety and Health at Work (EU-OSHA) highlights the importance of intergenerational knowledge sharing and mentoring programmes in retaining and valuing professional competencies.


For example, on-the-job coaching may focus on managing abnormal plant conditions. An experienced professional can share past cases, explain which anomalies required particular attention and reconstruct the decisions that helped maintain safety.


The colleague undergoing training must then have opportunities to apply this knowledge through supervised activities, exercises and practical assessments.


Incident analysis is another important tool.


Incidents, near misses and anomalies provide opportunities to reconstruct not only what happened, but also what information was available, how people interpreted the situation and which conditions influenced their decisions.


This form of learning helps preserve the memory of past events and turn it into shared knowledge.


The process should also involve people with different backgrounds and levels of experience.


The expertise of senior professionals can complement new technical knowledge, digital tools and perspectives introduced by younger colleagues.


The quality of the transfer depends on the organisation's ability to encourage this exchange, rather than associating valuable knowledge exclusively with years of service.


Why do leadership and human factors influence knowledge transfer?


Leadership and human factors shape knowledge transfer because they influence how people communicate, interpret risk and share information in everyday activities. An organisation can have detailed procedures and training tools yet still struggle to pass on experience.


This can happen when production pressure leaves insufficient time for coaching, employees are reluctant to voice concerns or supervisors cannot devote enough attention to competence development.


Cognitive biases can also affect the process.


An experienced professional may assume that certain knowledge is obvious when a colleague has never acquired it. Conversely, a less experienced employee may avoid asking questions for fear of appearing unprepared.


Leadership needs to recognise these dynamics and create conditions that support open discussion.


An environment in which people can ask questions, express uncertainty and discuss critical situations makes learning more effective.


This connection also reflects AR19's perspective on organisational culture, human factors and performance.


Safety does not depend solely on well-written procedures. It also depends on how people understand and apply them and how they respond to situations requiring professional judgement.


Knowledge transfer is therefore a shared responsibility involving leaders, supervisors, HSE teams, HR and operations.


It cannot rely exclusively on an experienced professional's willingness to share what they know.


How can knowledge transfer be integrated into safety management systems?


Knowledge transfer can form part of safety management systems through the identification of essential competencies, the planning of development activities and the verification of their effectiveness.


ISO 45001:2018 provides an international framework for occupational health and safety management, covering leadership, risk assessment, competence, worker participation and continual improvement. The standard does not mandate a single mentoring model. Instead, it requires a systematic approach to managing risks and the competencies needed for activities affecting occupational health and safety.


ISO 9001:2026, published on 16 September 2026, also provides a relevant reference for process management, quality and organisational knowledge.


These management systems offer a way to connect competence retention with operational management.


In practice, an organisation can include the risk of knowledge loss in its assessments, link essential competencies to operational roles and verify the effectiveness of development programmes.


Knowledge transfer should also accompany organisational changes.


New machinery, technological changes, turnover and departmental reorganisations can alter the knowledge required to work safely.


Competence availability therefore needs periodic review. Organisations should not treat it as a permanent condition once established.


Which KPIs can measure the risk of losing essential competencies?


KPIs can measure the risk of competence loss when they show how dependent an organisation is on concentrated knowledge and how effectively that knowledge is being shared. Traditional HR measures, such as turnover and training hours, provide useful information but do not fully describe an organisation's ability to retain essential capabilities.


They should be complemented by preventive indicators, or leading indicators, that reveal vulnerabilities before they lead to operational consequences.


One KPI may measure coverage of essential competencies: the percentage of activities for which the organisation has suitably qualified and authorised personnel.


Another indicator concerns dependence on individual professionals: how many critical activities can only be performed by one person?


A third measures completion of knowledge transfer programmes, distinguishing activities delivered from competencies actually demonstrated and assessed.


Other indicators may cover exercise quality, operational autonomy, documented knowledge and field observation results. However, the number of activities should never be confused with their effectiveness. An organisation could run numerous mentoring sessions without meaningfully reducing its dependence on one key professional.


Measurement should focus on outcomes: is the system less vulnerable to the loss of this knowledge today than it was before?


These leading indicators help identify weaknesses earlier, support better decisions and strengthen risk management and operational resilience through an approach that integrates people, processes and safety culture.


How can a company build a plan to transfer competencies essential to safety?


An effective plan starts by identifying the knowledge essential to safety and continues with structured transfer, practical application and verification.


The organisation can follow four stages.


Assessment of competencies and vulnerabilities


The first step is to analyse critical activities, processes and roles, identifying the knowledge that supports risk control.


Interviews, field observations and discussions with managers and supervisors can reveal organisational dependencies that do not appear in formal documentation.


Designing the transfer process


The second stage establishes priorities and selects the most suitable methods.


Mentoring, on-the-job coaching, incident reviews, simulations and updated procedures should reflect the characteristics of the knowledge being shared.


Developing and verifying competencies


Knowledge transfer needs real opportunities for application.


People must be able to use what they have learned under controlled conditions, receive feedback and progressively demonstrate that they can manage the required activities.


Monitoring and continual improvement


The final stage checks results through indicators and periodic assessments.


Management can then determine whether the programme has reduced organisational vulnerability and identify new priorities.


The process does not have to begin with a company-wide project.


It can start in one department, with one high-risk activity or with a competence that would be particularly difficult to replace.


What matters is connecting every initiative to a real operational need.


The AR19 approach: from individual knowledge to organisational risk management capability


Sharing competencies essential to safety is consistent with AR19's view of safety as part of business strategy and performance. The goal is not merely to ensure that people know the rules and procedures. It is to strengthen the organisation's ability to recognise risk, interpret weak signals and make effective decisions under real operating conditions.


The AR19 7Steps_Method© brings together safety culture assessment, employee engagement, leadership development, safety coaching, predictive KPIs and strategic review.


Applying these principles to knowledge management means understanding where essential capabilities are concentrated, how people share experience and which organisational conditions may obstruct learning.


Through assessment, safety coaching and leadership development, AR19 helps organisations strengthen the human and organisational factors that shape risk management.


From this perspective, knowledge transfer is not separate from safety culture.


It is one of its practical components: it helps make competencies accessible, behaviours more informed and decisions less dependent on single individuals.


Conclusion: a role can be replaced, but organisational capability must be built


Losing an experienced professional does not necessarily reduce safety.


Risk emerges when the organisation has not identified the knowledge on which it depends and lacks adequate ways to retain and share it.


Managing essential competencies therefore requires attention before retirement, reassignment or organisational change occurs.


Companies need to understand their dependencies, develop shared competencies and verify that people can manage risks under real operating conditions.


The real objective is not to preserve one person's experience, but to transform it into a capability the organisation can maintain, develop and improve over time.


That is the difference between replacing a role and protecting the knowledge that sustains safety, reliability and operational continuity.


Frequently asked questions about knowledge transfer and workplace safety


What is a Knowledge Loss Risk Assessment?


A Knowledge Loss Risk Assessment identifies and evaluates the risk of losing essential organisational knowledge and competencies. It considers their importance, their concentration in a few individuals and the likelihood of their becoming unavailable. It helps companies prioritise knowledge retention and transfer.


How can a company prevent the loss of know-how when an employee retires?


The company should identify the employee's essential competencies early and arrange mentoring, on-the-job coaching and documentation of practical experience. Before the professional leaves, it should verify that other people have genuinely acquired the capabilities needed.


What does competence assurance mean in workplace safety?


Competence assurance refers to the processes through which an organisation defines, develops, assesses and maintains the competencies required to perform activities safely. It goes beyond training attendance and considers whether people can apply their knowledge and skills under real operating conditions.


What is the difference between tacit and explicit knowledge?


Explicit knowledge consists of information that an organisation can record and share through manuals, procedures and information systems. Tacit knowledge develops mainly through experience and includes judgement, practical insights and the ability to interpret operating situations.


Is mentoring mandatory for ISO 45001 certification?


ISO 45001 requires organisations to manage the competencies needed for occupational health and safety, but it does not prescribe mentoring as a mandatory method. Mentoring is one of the tools a company may choose to develop and transfer competencies according to its activities and risks.


Sources


Health and Safety Executive – Training and Competence



Health and Safety Executive – Human Factors Inspectors Toolkit



European Agency for Safety and Health at Work – Knowledge Transfer, Training and Life-long Learning



European Agency for Safety and Health at Work – OSH Management in the Context of an Ageing Workforce



International Journal of Nuclear Knowledge Management – Risk Management of Knowledge Loss in Nuclear Industry Organisations



ISO – ISO 45001:2018, Occupational Health and Safety Management Systems



ISO – ISO 9001:2026, Quality Management Systems



Comments


AR19 logo - Security Consulting

Where to find us

Registered office

Via Palmanova 4,

20132 Milan

Operational Headquarters

Private Street Antonio Picozzi 20, 20131 Milan

Contact us

Telephone:

+39 02 40700880

E-mail:

info@ar19.eu

VAT and Tax Code:

10732020960

Follow us on social media

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube

Let's get to know each other better

bottom of page